MBA HR Case study analysis on "Making the right Choice" using Big Five Model of Personality - Selection of Right Candidate for Task Force Leader

 Making the right Choice!!!!

A manager Kokila is in the process of deciding which of the two persons she will appoint as task force leader. The task is to develop a new approach to marketing an already established product. She has observed Akhil, who is quiet and reserved and interacts relatively with his work peers. He is very bright, a hard worker and very reliable in doing structured work. He has never been observed to express either positive or negative emotions.

The other candidate Urmi is talkative and outgoing. She interacts easily with others and has a warm, outgoing style. She is sometimes careless about details and easily bored with repetitive routine work. However she enjoys solving new problem and makes good decision in vague situations. Her peers can tell what Urmi is feeling as she is quite expressive, but she has never let her emotions out of control when under stress. The more difficult the problem, the more she enjoys it.

Question

Using the Big Five Model of Personality, Who according to you will be appointed as task force leader and why?                                                     

In this case, personality theory of Industrial Psychology has been applied.

Application of Five force model of personality to decide over selection of task leader between Urmi and Akhil:

Openness to Experience

The openness to experience dimension of personality is characterized by a willingness to try new activities. People with higher levels of openness are amenable to unconventional ideas and beliefs, including those which challenge their existing assumptions. They are more open to unfamiliar cultures and customs. People with low levels of openness are wary of uncertainty and the unknown. They are more suspicious of beliefs and ideas which challenge their status quo. They feel uncomfortable in unfamiliar situations and prefer familiar environments. Less open individuals value the safety of predictability, and like to adhere to well-known traditions and routines.

Urmi enjoys solving new problems and makes good decision in vague situation. However, Akhil is good at doing structured work. He is comfortable in familiar situation and not in unknown situation. He falls in low level of openness to experience. Personality of Urmi falls in high level of openness. She is better than Akhil in terms of openness to experience.

Conscientiousness

People who are conscientious are more aware of their actions and the consequences of their behavior than people who are unconscientious. They feel a sense of responsibility towards other and are generally careful to carry out the duties assigned to them. People with high conscientious levels also exhibit more goal-oriented behavior. Low levels of conscientiousness are reflected in less motivated behavior. Unconscientious individuals are less concerned by tidiness and punctuality. This may result in them arriving late to appointments and meetings, and being more relaxed in setting life goals. Unconscientious people tend to engage in more impulsive behavior.

Both Urmi and Akhil exhibits high level of conscientiousness as both of them carry out their duties and responsibilities assigned to them. Both possess goal oriented behaviour. Both are punctual and do not reflect impulsive behaviour at work. Hence on conscientiousness scale, both reflects more or less same level of tendency.

Extraversion

Extraversion is characterized by outgoing, socially confident behavior. Extraverts are sociable, talkative and often forward in social situations. They enjoy being the center of a group and will often seek the attention of others. Extraverts enjoy meeting new people and are happy to introduce themselves to strangers, thriving in company of others. This personality trait is measured on a introversion-extraversion continuum. Introverts are people with low levels of extraversion, display contrasting behavior. They are quieter and often feel shy around other people. They may feel intimidated being in large groups such as parties, and will often try to avoid demanding social gatherings. Introverts enjoy being a part of smaller social groups, preferably with familiar people. Such behavior results in introverts tending to enjoy smaller social networks, but instead they maintain a close group of trusted friends.

To become a task leader for marketing an established product, extraversion is utmost important. This quality is possessed by Urmi. Urmi is talkative and outgoing. She interacts easily with others and has a warm, outgoing style. She is quite expressive but Akhil is quiet and reserved and interacts relatively with his work peers. Hence Urmi is better candidate than Akhil considering this trait of personality.

Agreeableness

Individuals who score highly on agreeableness measures are friendly and co-operative. Often considered more likeable by their peers and colleagues, agreeable people are trusting of others and are more altruistic, willing to help others during times of need.. Agreeable people dislike being involved in arguments, conflict with others and other forms of confrontation. They seek to pacify and appease others, acting as the mediating ‘peace-maker’ of their group. Individuals who are disagreeable score lower on this dimension of personality. They are less concerned with pleasing other people and making friends. Disagreeable individuals are more suspicious of other people’s intentions and are less charitable. Instead, they are motivated to act in accordance with their self-interest, showing less regard for the needs of others. As a result, they are perceived by others as being more selfish than agreeable personalities.

On Agreeableness part, Urmi is more agreeable than Akhil as Urmi helps people in solving issues of vague nature. Her peers can tell what Urmi is feeling as she is quite expressive. This indicates she maintains friendly relationship with her peers and cooperates with them. However, no such behaviour of Akhil is exhibited or given in the case.

Neuroticism

This personality dimension is measured on a continuum ranging from emotional stability to emotional instability, or neuroticism. People with high neuroticism scores are more fearful and often feel anxious, over-thinking their problems and exaggerating their significance. Rather than seeing the positive in a situation, they may dwell on its negative aspects. People with low neuroticism scores are less preoccupied by these negative concerns. They are able to remain calmer in response to stressful situations, and view problems in proportion to their importance. As a result, they tend to worry about such problems to a lesser extent.

On neuroticism sacale, Urmi weighs higher than Akhil. Urmi is quite expressive, but she has never let her emotions out of control when under stress thus showing less neuroticism as required by a task leader. Akhil has never been observed to express either positive or negative emotions but whether he remains calm in stressful situation or not is not clear in the case. Hence Urmi is a better option for task leader than Akhil on neuroticism scale.

Conclusion:

Urmi should be selected as task force leader because she fits team leader role better than Akhil. Her confidence, efficiency, energy, warmth and originality led to her being appointed as team leader.

MBA Case study solution - "Financial Management at Hero Honda Motors Ltd Case study solution"- dividend policy, working capital management, investment policy, financing policy of Hero Honda Motors, factors of zero debt capital for Hero Honda

 

 Financial Management at Hero Honda Motors Ltd Case study solution

Q1.Is the financing policy of Hero Honda Motors satisfactory? How is the unlevered capital structure of the firm justified?

The financing policy of Hero Honda Motors Ltd. shows that its capital structure is mainly composed of equity and very less debt. This can be understood from a comparatively low debt-equity ratio of the company.

The debt equity ratio of hero Honda is continuously decreasing over the years. It is lowest in 2006, which is 0.09. As compared to the competitor Bajaj Auto ltd. the debt equity ratio is very low.

Debt Equity Ratio = Total Liabilities / Shareholder’s equity

This is a satisfactory policy, as company has lesser liabilities from outside and more of the finances from inside sources only.

The most common disadvantage to the use of debt is the financial distress that debt can exert on a company. Companies that have a high debt-to-equity ratio in their capital structure may see an increased risk in potential bankruptcy.  Hence the shareholder’s equity is more than total liabilities. Low debt equity ratio indicates low financial risk. Low liabilities shows that financial risk associated with the company in terms of fixed cost obligation of paying interest to outside parties is negligible. Unlevered capital structure firm is financed by equity only. The zero debt policy is compensated by large shareholder’s equity. Since Hero Honda Motors ltd. is very famous and profitable company, the number of shareholders is large in number. Since it is a Joint Venture, funds and financing activities both are needed in excess. In a joint venture the number of employees is large; hence more money is needed to feed them. But company has fulfilled it needs beautifully.

2.What are the factors that are favoring a zero debt capital for the company? Is it always beneficial to have a low debt in the capital structure?

A Zero debt company is one which has not borrowed any money from banks, financial institutions or others for long or medium term requirements or for working capital. Since there's no debt, the company will have no commitment for repayment or servicing of interest The financing mix of Hero Honda has decreased from 2001 to 2006, which shows the company is doing quietly very well, whereas the debt equity ratio of competitive company Bajaj auto limited has shown increase in the successive years. A company's reasonable, proportional use of debt and equity to support its assets is a key indicator of balance sheet strength. A healthy capital structure that reflects a low level of debt and a corresponding high level of equity is a very positive sign of investment quality. The factors that are supporting zero debt capital of the company are: 

·        Sufficient amount of equity share capital.

·        High profit earning, and an increasing rate every year, provide more money to the company. 

·        The company has very less liability in theØ form of debt; hence whole profit can be easily employed back in the company.

3.Is investment policy driving the growth of the firm? What are the key issues that the investment policy of the company is trying to address?

Yes, we can say that investment policy is driving the growth of Hero Honda; as we observed from the case that finance managers use different combinations of various polices to meet the financial requirements of the company at least cost and risk and for the long term benefit of the company like expansion , increasing the plant capacity in case of to meet the market demand and sustain its market share and leadership in the automobile sector of India The key issues that the investment policies of the company addresses are: 

·        Meeting the current growing market demand in short term.

·        Increasing the plant capacity for expansion.

·        Establishment of new plants in the country keeping in mind the long term demand in future. 

·        To improve its efficiency and to cut down the cost, by investing forØ augmenting its welding capacity. 

·        Investment in new and latest technology will enable, the company to cater to future market demand and consolidate its market.

5.Is the dividend policy of the firm appropriate? What factors determine the existing dividend policy of the firm?

Yes, the dividend policy of the firm is appropriate as there is an increasing trend in the price of the shares of Hero Honda Motors Ltd. which shows that the trust of the investors and the profit of the company are gradually increasing. The company has performed well increasing the shareholders’ value. The decisions relating to the Dividend of the Shares is justified as the company is rolling out 1000% dividend per share for the third year in succession. Also the dividend per share on the company’s share is 20. The company is following a liberal dividend policy.

 MBA – Financial Management – Semester 2

Case 2 - Financial Management at Hero Honda Motors Ltd

 

Background

Hero Honda Motors Limited came into existence on 19 January 1984. The company was formed by creating a joint venture between Hero Group and the Honda Motor Company of Japan. Owned by Hero (Munjal) Group, the company's current Chairman is Mr Brij Mohan Lai Munjal and Mr Pawan Kant Munjal is its Managing Director. The promoters of the company hold approximately 29% of the equity shares and the Indian public holds 9% of the total shares, while the institutional investors hold about 35%.

The company produces motorcycles and scooters. Some of the brand names of its products are Achiever, Karizma, CBZ, Splendor, Super Splendor, Splendor Plus, Glamour, Passion, Passion Plus, CD Deluxe, CD 100 SS, Sleek, and CD Dawn. The company also manufactures the spare parts of these two wheelers. Besides, the company provides mobile after-sales service to its existing customers. The company has two plants located in Haryana, one at Dharuhera and the other at Gurgaon. In a little over two decades, it has emerged as the world's largest manufacturer of bicycles and a global leader in motorcycles. The company has sold over 15 million motorcycles and has consistently grown at double digits since its inception and today, every second motorcycle sold in the country is a Hero Honda. Hero Honda is a world leader because of its excellent manpower, proven management, extensive dealer network, efficient supply chain, and world-class products with cutting edge technology from Honda Motor Company, Japan.

Progressively through the 1980s, the 1990s, and now in the 2000s, Hero Honda has relied on 3 R's—reach, research, and reliability as its basic building blocks. Using feedback from the market, a fully-equipped R&D centre has consistently created best practices in designing, testing, and harmonization, besides placing strong emphasis on road safety and ride quality. This emphasis has helped Hero Honda build products that are ahead of their time. Hero Honda became the first company in India to prove that it was possible to drive a vehicle without polluting the roads. The company introduced new generation motorcycles that set industry benchmarks for fuel thrift and low emission.

Financing Policy

The company has been a debt-free company for the last five years. The unsecured loan of Rs 186 crores from the state government of Haryana on account of sales tax deferment is interest-free and has no holding costs. The company has been meeting its expansion and growth needs from its internal sources of financing. The financing mix of the company for the past six years has been as follows (Table A):

 

Table A Financing mix of Hero Honda

Time	Debt-equity ratio
March 2001	0.11
March 2002	0.17
March 2003	0.16
March 2004	0.15
March 2005	0.15
March 2006	0.09

 

The financing mix of the closest competitor, Bajaj Auto Ltd, stood as follows (Table B):

 

Table B Financing mix of Bajaj Auto Ltd

Time	Debt-equity ratio
March 2003	0.25
March 2004	0.27
March 2005	0.29
March 2006	0.30

 

 

Performance

The executive summary of Hero Honda Ltd is as follows (Table C):                                                           (Rs in crores)

 

	Mar-01	Mar-02	Mar-03	Mar-04	Mar-05	Mar-06
Net sales	3171.22	4466.48	5097.95	5833.01	7419.86	8708.13
Other income	10.63	47.21	23.25	53.6	44.05	75.81
Cost of production	2581.28	3463.47	3922.35	4502.45	5842.09	6878.7
PBDIT	459.55	750.01	903.65	1054.6	1227.21	1438.05
PBDT	424.45	717.09	878.83	1031.65	1209.45	1422.47
PBT	380.18	666.08	815.44	958.32	1120.07	1307.85
PAT	250.1	434.63	511.64	614.18	713.29	866.95
Gross fixed assets	614.66	704.52	780.88	901.45	1074.73	1421.54
Current assets	663.83	536.46	1666.57	2068.8	2577.72	2850.92
Net worth	608.99	675.54	860.33	1138.81	1493.38	2009.33
Equity capital	39.94	39.94	39.94	39.94	39.94	39.94
Long term borrowings	66.48	116.44	134.28	174.7	201.76	185.78
Capital employed	675.47	791.98	994.61	1313.51	1695.14	2195.11
Current liabilities & provisions	460.12	880.21	1116.21	1260.05	1500.47	1562.8
Total assets/liabilities	1125.47	1733.34	2176.67	2652.08	3294.68	3875.07
			Growth (%)
Gross Sales	40.97	40.75	14.22	32.24	27.42	17.32
Cost of production	41.61	34.18	13.25	14.79	29.75	17.74
PBDIT	34.19	63.21	20.49	16.7	16.37	17.18
PAT	35.66	73.78	17.72	20.04	16.14	21.54
GFA	22.45	14.62	9.3	13.95	19.09	29.27
Total Assets	33.26	54.01	25.58	21.84	24.23	17.62
Profitability Ratios (%)
PAT/ Sales	7.87	9.72	10.02	9.09	8.29	8.59
PAT / Net worth	47.52	67.67	66.63	61.44	54.2	49.5
PAT/ Total Assets	25.39	30.41	26.17	25.44	23.99	24.18
PAT/ Capital Employed	42.75	59.24	57.28	53.22	47.42	44.57

 

 Investment Policy

The company keeps on increasing the production capacity from time to time to cope up with the rising demand. During the year 2005-06, the company added Rs 399 crores in fixed assets to expand the manufacturing capacity. The production capacity of Gurgaon plant was increased from 5000 to 6500 units a day in the previous year. To tap the increasing demand for the motorbikes, the company decided to carry the process of expansion further and increase the capacity at the Dharuhera plant to 6500 units by the fall of 2006. This would take the installed capacity to roll out 13000 units a day. This capacity expansion will take care of the growing demand in the short run. The company is in the process of setting up a third plant to take care of the demand in the medium-term as it would also enable the company to realize its mandate of becoming a global scale and world-class manufacturer. A state-of-the-art manufacturing plant with an investment of Rs 400 crores to be operational by mid 2007 at Haridwar with an initial production capacity of Rs 5,00,000 is proposed. Besides, the company, in order to improve its efficiency and to cut down the cost, has made investment in augmenting its welding capacity. The company has also invested in technology that will help in localizing the production of gear boxes. By 2010, Hero Honda and its ancillaries will invest Rs 1900 crores in the new plant, achieving a capacity expansion to 15 lakh units, thereby enabling the company to cater to future market demand and consolidate its market leadership.

 

Working Capital

The company has already endeavoured to set benchmarks in its working capital management and has continued to operate on negative working capital for the past several years. The continued focus on working capital has helped the company to enhance cash flows through better management of inventory, receivables, and payables. As a part of cost rationalization drive, the company has aggressively availed cash discount from its vendors by making the payments before due date. This has not only helped to improve its operating margins but has also allowed it to deploy the surplus funds in its core business operations. The tight monitoring and control of the working capital components has been the main source of satisfactory working capital management, which is reflected in the following figures:

Table D Working capital management and liquidity ratios

	2004-05	2005-06
Inventory period (days)	11.30	10.50
Operating cycle (days)	14.00	14.90
Cash cycle (days)	-33.00	-23.90
Current ratio	0.53	0.74
Acid-test ratio	0.34	0.54

 

The company has made sustained efforts to prune manufacturing variable costs over the years through the process of localization and process improvement. To a large extent, these costs have been controlled and the cost per vehicle came down from Rs 837 to Rs 353 in March 2005. However, due to sharp increase in the cost of electricity and its erratic supply, the declining trend in the variable manufacturing costs was reversed in 2005-06. To address this problem, the company has commissioned HFO-based generator sets at each of its facilities. In the coming months and years, these measures will help Hero Honda to prune its material and manufacturing costs substantially.

As 60-70% of the revenue of the company is made up of material costs, vendor management is a critical factor. To improve plant efficiency and inventory turns, the company has extended Just-In-Time (JIT) beyond the shop floor. An online vendor connectivity programme has been implemented and extended to 94 vendors from 46 in the previous year. As a result, the company has been able to access 70% of the materials (in value terms) by maintaining zero inventory. For the balance, the average inventory period is about 34 days. The cost of raw materials as a percentage of total sales decreased from 70.1% in 2004-05 to 69.5% in 2005-06 primarily due to favourable changes in sales mix and continued focus on cost rationalization. To rationalize the supply chain further, the company is now switching to system purchases and also looking at the possibilities for global procurements. The working capital performance of Hero Honda Motors Ltd. is given in Table E.

Compared to the company, the working capital cycle of the other firms in the automobile sector was as follows:

Table E Working capital performance of Hero Honda Motors Ltd

 

	March	March	March	March	March	March
	2001	2002	2003	2004	2005	2006
Working Capital in crore)	203.71	-343.75	550.36	808.75	1077.25	1284.57
Average current assets (Rs in crore)	488.89	600.14	1101.51	1867.68	2323.26	2714.32
Avg. days of debtors	4	5	8	5	2	4
Avg. days of creditors	31	32	35	42	40	32
Gross working capital cycle (days)	33	27	28	22	16	17
Net working capital cycle (days)	2	-5	-7	-20	-24	-15
Liquidity ratios (times)
Current ratio	1.44	0.61	1.49	1.64	1.72	1.82
Quick ratio	0.18	0.25	1.21	1.30	1.42	1.52
Interest cover	11.83	21.23	33.85	42.76	64.07	84.94

  

Table F Working capital cycle of automobile companies

 

	2004		2005		2006
Company name	Gross working capital cycle	Net working capital cycle	Gross working capital cycle	Net working capital cycle	Gross working capital cycle	Net working capital cycle
	(in days)
Bajaj Auto	30.38	-15.43	24.18	-18.76	14.24	-10.56
Maharashtra Scooters	69.49	-74.21	78.40	-72.33	108.66	-63.08
TVS Motors	39.31	-11.93	38.71	-14.23	42.30	-11.01
Yamaha	113.16	50.38	85.01	44.85	94.29	54.45

 

Dividend

The company has been continuing with a liberal dividend policy during the past few years. The company believes that the shareholders should benefit appropriately from the company's continued success consis­tently. The company is extremely conscious about the efficient use of capital employed and has always endeavoured to earn a return higher than the cost. Further, after giving due consideration to the cash gener­ating capacity, expected capital needs of the business and strategic considerations, the board has recommended a dividend of 1000% for the third year in succession.

 

Table G : Dividend Payout by Hero Honda

Year	Dividends (Rs in crore)	Retained earnings (Rs in crore)	Total Dividend Rate (in percentage)	Dividend per share (in Rs)
March 2001	66.01	180.86	150	NA
March 2002	349.67	113.26	850	17
March 2003	405.49	175.27	900	18
March 2004 March 2005 March 2006	450.54 455.90 455.39	277.78 354.57 515.95	1000 1000 1000	20 20 20

 

The dividend payout by BAJAJ Auto Ltd. during past four years was as follows:

Year	Dividends per share (in Rs)	Payout ratio (%)
March 2003	14.00	29.68
March 2004 March 2005 March 2006	25.00 25.00 40.00	38.64 39.55 41.89

 

The adjusted closing prices of shares of Hero Honda Motors Ltd were as follows:

Year	Share Price (in Rs)
March 2001	140.35
March 2002	333.70
March 2003	188.40
March 2004	490.45
March 2005	548.15
March 2006	888.30

 

Discuss

1.    Is the financing policy of Hero Honda Motors satisfactory? How is the unlevered capital structure of the firm justified?

2.    What are the factors that are favoring a zero debt capital for the company? Is it always beneficial to have a low debt in the capital structure?

3.     Is investment policy driving the growth of the firm? What are the key issues that the investment policy of the company is trying to address?

4.    Are you satisfied with the working capital management of the company? Give reasons.

5.     Is the dividend policy of the firm appropriate? What factors deter­mine the existing dividend policy of the firm?